Hello everyone,
I’d like to discuss some things relating to HSK courses, and also to the HSK courses that were made by BenWhateley.
Especially now that the feature to automatically ignore items that have already been learned is gone, I think that the format of the HSK that were made by BenWhateley doesn’t work very well. If someone learns all of the items in the HSK 1 course, now when they go to learn the items in the HSK 2 course, they have to either relearn everything that they learned in the HSK 1 course or manually ignore items that they already learned. When they go to learn HSK 3, etc., they have to do the same thing.
An argument can be made here that people should just start learning at the highest HSK level that they hope to complete, but I think there are some advantages to starting at HSK 1 and working your way up. The fact that many vocabulary items was spread across more than one of the courses was always an issue, too, as often an error would be corrected, an alternative answer would get added, or a definition would get changed in one course but not in another.
I understand that people don’t want to make major revisions to these courses because it would disturb the people who already learned the items in the courses, but I think something needs to be done, in the form of making some new courses. Do people agree?
Also, while we’re discussing this, do people think it’s helpful for the course to have all of the “building blocks” that are used in characters that are in the HSK list, or would it be better to just have the words that are in the HSK list? Personally, I think it might be better to just have the words from the HSK lists. I kind of like the idea of having all of the building blocks included, but I think that in actuality, it just makes learning too slow, and in fact, it might often be better to first learn the word from the HSK list and then afterwards learn the building blocks, perhaps in a separate course.
If we do make a new course, something that I’d like to discuss is possibly adding three way testing to the course: Showing characters and testing on pinyin, showing characters and testing on English, and showing English and testing on characters. I realize that some people don’t like testing by showing English and having people type characters, but to me, it sometimes feels like I know what the characters mean, and I know how to pronounce them, but when I’m actually talking to people and I need to think of how to say an English word in Chinese, it’s not there, and I think that showing English and having people type Chinese might help fix this. However, this isn’t something that I’m sure about, and if people really don’t want this, then I understand.
Finally, if there anyone who would want to champion this? @DrewSSP, you’ve been doing some good work with your HSK level 6 course. Did you generate the course with scripts, and if so, how hard would it be to do the same thing for the other HSK levels?